top of page

Early Achievement Does Not Guarantee Long-Term Success: Lessons from Finland and Beyond

4 days ago
6 min read

Child prodigies have a powerful pull on the media and on parents alike. Most of us have heard inspiring stories of extraordinary talent that showed itself almost as soon as a child could walk. Take Novak Djokovic: he picked up a tennis racket at four, left home for professional training in Germany at twelve, and won his first Grand Slam title at twenty. Stories like his have quietly shaped a script that many families now treat as the gold standard: spot talent as early as possible, specialise, train intensively from early childhood, and so pave the way to greatness.



Education science and developmental psychology tell a different story. A major review published in Science in December 2025 by Arne Güllich and colleagues challenges that belief at its root: early-blooming success stories like Djokovic's are rare exceptions, not the general rule of human development.


What the data actually shows


To reach this conclusion, Güllich and colleagues from RPTU Kaiserslautern-Landau, the University of Innsbruck, Michigan State University and Purdue University brought together research on the development of 34,839 people who reached world-class level in their fields: Olympic medallists, the world's highest-rated chess players, leading classical composers and Nobel laureates in the sciences.


The findings unsettle the "hothouse" model of training. Across the fields studied, the people who were the best when young and the people who became the best as adults were, for the most part, not the same individuals. Among the world's top-ten chess players, for instance, the youth and adult lists were nearly 90% different people. Put simply, most world-class adults were not prodigies, and most prodigies did not go on to become world-class adults.


Arne Güllich and colleagues analysed the development of 34,839 world-class performers across sport, chess, music and science.
Outstanding achievement in childhood does not predict long-term success.

The review also found that standout achievement in childhood does not predict long-term success. At the very highest levels, early performance was even slightly negatively correlated with adult peak performance. In other words, shining very early did not make a child more likely to reach the world's top tier; if anything, the relationship pointed the other way. This is a correlation rather than proof of cause, but it is a clear signal for families who feel pressure to push early.


The true greats usually took a very different path. Their early years in their eventual field were often unremarkable, no more impressive than those of their peers. Rather than being locked into one demanding regime, they spent years trying a range of sports, arts and other pursuits, and specialised much later. Yet once they found their passion and committed to one field, their rate of progress accelerated, carrying them past many who had specialised from the start.


What leading education systems tell us


Beyond the Science review, evidence from education systems around the world points in the same direction: towards late blooming and broad exploration.


First, Finland. Children there do not begin formal teaching of reading, writing and mathematics until around seven, after a year of pre-primary education at six. Before that, Finland's National Core Curriculum for Early Childhood Education and Care places play at the heart of learning and sets out transversal competences, such as thinking and learning, self-expression, managing daily life and participation. Children build these through play, social interaction, self-care routines and time in nature rather than through drills, laying a broad foundation on which later academic learning can rest.


Child prodigies have a powerful pull on the media and on parents alike.
Growing up is a marathon, not a sprint.

Second, New Zealand. A well-known longitudinal study from the University of Otago, Children learning to read later catch up to children reading earlier (Suggate, Schaughency & Reese, 2013), offers reassurance to parents anxious about early reading. It compared children taught to read from age five with children who began at seven. The early readers had an initial advantage, but it had disappeared by age eleven, and in a second comparison the later starters showed slightly stronger reading comprehension. The authors suggest that rich early experiences with spoken language, stories and play may matter more for long-term reading than an early start on decoding letters.


Third, South Korea. Many children attend hagwon, private cramming academies, from the preschool years. Korea's 2024 Youth Risk Behaviour Survey, released by the Ministry of Education and the Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency, found that 42.3% of middle and high school students reported high levels of stress. Heavy academic loading from a very young age risks wearing down intrinsic motivation, the natural curiosity that keeps people wanting to learn for life. When learning is driven mainly by outside pressure, children can come to see it as something done for others rather than for themselves.


Finally, China. The word jiwa (鸡娃, "chicken-blood children") describes parents pushing children through back-to-back classes to compete for places at elite schools. In 2021, the government introduced its "double reduction" policy to limit homework and for-profit tutoring, an official recognition of the strain this places on children. When childhood is narrowed to a single academic track, there is less room for the adaptability, flexibility and creativity that an AI-shaped future will increasingly ask of them.


Why late bloomers often go further


To explain why broad exploration tends to lead further than early specialisation, the Science review puts forward three hypotheses. They are explanations still being tested rather than settled conclusions, but each fits well with what developmental psychology tells us:


  • Search and match: Childhood is a time for trying things out. When a child is free to explore many activities, from modelling clay and painting to running outdoors and caring for a plant, they are trying on different versions of themselves. This variety raises the chance of finding a genuine passion and real aptitude, rather than following a path chosen for them by adults.


  • Enhanced learning capital: Learning many different skills does not scatter a child's thinking. Meeting different problems in different settings helps children learn how to learn, and that flexibility becomes a strong foundation. When they later choose a field to commit to, they can build expertise much faster.


  • Limited risks: Young children's bodies and nervous systems are still developing. Delaying specialisation helps protect them from overuse injuries caused by repeating the same movements, and from boredom, performance pressure and early burnout.


What this means for parents


Taken together, this evidence sends a clear message to educators and parents: it is time to rethink what success looks like for young children. Pushing children to excel early may satisfy short-term expectations and produce children who shine on the surface. Raising happy, adaptable people who can reach high levels later in life asks for something different: patience, and a much wider path.


At HEI Schools Saigon Central, the Finnish idea of exploring broadly before going deep comes to life every day.
Why place on a four- or five-year-old the pressure to be exceptional?

At HEI Schools Saigon Central, the Finnish principle of exploring broadly before going deep comes to life every day. Children are not assessed on whether they can read early or recite their times tables at five. Instead, the teachers draw flexibly on project-based learning, purposeful learning through play and inquiry-based learning. Through projects such as "Dough" and "Under the Sea", children nurture their natural curiosity and creativity, practise active participation with others and, most importantly, discover the joy of learning for its own sake.


Growing up is a marathon, not a sprint. If a 25- or 30-year-old who has not yet stood out among their peers is not failing, but simply still searching for the piece that fits their life, why place on a four- or five-year-old the pressure to be exceptional?


Parenting asks for patience and a deep trust in each child's natural pace of development. Let children be children. Give them a safe, loving environment where they can play freely, make mistakes, try hundreds of new things and slowly find their own light. The respect and understanding parents offer today are the firmest foundation for the happy, genuine "stars" of tomorrow.

References

  • Güllich, A., Barth, M., Hambrick, D. Z., & Macnamara, B. N. (2025). Recent discoveries on the acquisition of the highest levels of human performance. Science, 390(6779). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adt7790

  • Suggate, S. P., Schaughency, E. A., & Reese, E. (2013). Children learning to read later catch up to children reading earlier. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 28(1), 33–48.

  • Finnish National Agency for Education. (2022). National core curriculum for early childhood education and care 2022. Helsinki: EDUFI.

  • Ministry of Education & Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency. (2024). Korea Youth Risk Behaviour Survey 2024.



Further reading



bottom of page